Is Custom Software Better than Off-the-Shelf for Startups?

Modern businesses need to have the right software in place to succeed, but with numerous options in the off-the-shelf software to custom development marketplace, it can be difficult to know which path is best. It's essential for companies embarking on this journey of discovery during the project phase to analyze their short-term needs as well as long-term term goals before making a choice. Here we provide an overview of the two approaches to obtaining software, highlighting their associated pros and cons so you make confident decisions about what works for your business now and into the future.

Terminology: Others terms used for custom software include bespoke and proprietary. Likewise, off-the-shelf software can be called packaged. Custom software is built to your specific need and can be performed by an in-house developer team or an external software development company. Read on for the advantages and disadvantages of off-the-shelf software vs custom software.

Custom Software

If you're looking for a bespoke software solution to fit your business requirements, then custom development may be the best option. You'll work closely with a team of software developers from start to finish in order to build your first Minimum Viable Product (MVP). That is something tailored specifically to you and your needs to get the software your business needs up and running.

This could involve utilizing open-source solutions as foundations before undergoing rigorous planning, coding processes, testing phases and final tweaks. However, when all is said and done - it's yours. A unique piece of tech that can adapt effortlessly to any change or growth within your company structure.

Let's review the pros and cons of custom software development.

Pros of Custom Software Development

1. Flexibility and No Limits

With custom software solutions, businesses can create a solution that is tailored to meet and exceed their specific needs. The flexibility they offer means you are no longer restricted by out-of-the-box features or design elements. Instead, the development of each project can be moulded around your individual business goals, challenges and requirements.

2. Scalability

You're the one who creates the code and owns the custom software. It means that you get the complete freedom to shape the software according to your liking at any time of its lifecycle. If the project or company expands, your software solution can easily scale with it.

3. Ease of Integration

When developing custom software, the tech stack and purpose are carefully curated to ensure it will fit perfectly within an existing business environment. It also provides the potential for seamless integration with future assets. Whereas off-the-shelf solutions can often be incompatible or restrictive when attempting to integrate third-party plugins, posing a much greater challenge in getting your desired outcomes achieved efficiently.

Cons of Custom Software Development

1. Possibly More Resources Required

While the thought of a custom solution may require larger investments in terms of finances and time, it is worth considering. Thorough planning, elegant wireframing and design along with an experienced development team are required to bring such projects to life. Therefore, plan ahead for any extra MVP cost or extended deployment timelines when determining whether off-the-shelf software would suffice over producing something unique from scratch.

2. Need to Hire a Development Team to Create the Custom Software

People are essential for making custom software solutions a success. Whilst you have an in-house team, they may not be able to take on the project without sacrificing existing tasks, meaning recruitment procedures become necessary. Thus it is important to carefully consider whether your current resources can effectively manage both core business processes and external projects simultaneously before engaging additional help.

Use Cases for Custom Software

When does it make sense to invest in creating custom software?

• If already existing solutions can't fulfil your business requirements;
• when you want to create something unique;
• in case your startup budget allows you to create a custom solution;
• if you have a fast-growing business and you need software that allows you to scale.

Off-the-Shelf Software

Ready-made software is the go-to tool for many businesses. An inexpensive and accessible solution, it's a mass-market product designed to fit any size enterprise in any field of endeavour. And because so many use this type of product, insights from user reviews are readily available, allowing you to make an informed decision quickly and get up and running even faster.

So what makes off-the-shelf software worth it and which drawbacks can you come across?

Pros of Off-the-Shelf Software

1. Competitive pricing

Off-the-shelf software products have a very reasonable price because they are offered to a broad audience. Package solutions usually have more than one pricing plan, as well as special offers when paid annually. Therefore in most cases, it will be cheaper to go for off-the-shelf software than develop a custom one.

2. Easy launch and faster time to market

Ready-made software solutions have revolutionized the way we design, develop and deploy business applications. With features already included out of the box and rapid automated installation or ready building block type constructors. It is now possible to launch an MVP within significantly shorter timeframes than was previously achievable with custom programming. Whether you are looking for a fast rollout period or simply want to get things done quickly, off-the-shelf software could be just what your project needs.

3. Included maintenance and support

Don't stress about making frequent improvements to your package solution, that's the responsibility of the provider. Their upgrades, tweaks and maintenance are included in their offering so you can rest assured knowing they'll take care of any necessary enhancements for you.

Should anything not perform as expected, customer support is available at a moment's notice. However, be sure to double-check if such services are within the given package or require additional payment.

Cons of Off-the-Shelf Software

1. Compatibility challenges

The business world is full of surprises and challenges. If you decide to get an off-the-shelf software solution, make sure it can be integrated with your current environment. It may look simple but installation often requires a few tweaks for everything to fit together perfectly. Don't forget that compatibility issues can take time and energy from your team, so make sure the package works seamlessly before implementing anything in production.

2. Lack of flexibility

Although the convenience of prepackaged software may seem appealing, its short-term benefit could give way to long-term disappointment. As your business or project evolves, off-the-shelf solutions can become inadequate and require customizing, which often proves costly and time-consuming with limited success.

3. Downtime

The decision to release a newer version of the provider's software promises improved performance, additional security and up-to-date features. This could be great news. However, such updates are typically accompanied by unavoidable restrictions that may affect your operations. In cases where an issue arises on their end, you must rely solely on them for resolution until it is fixed.

Use Cases for Off-the-Shelf Software

In which scenarios is it wise to opt for off-the-shelf software?

• If the package solution covers all your needs;
• when you have limited time and money;
• and you don't plan to scale and change the purchased solution.

Off-the-Shelf vs Custom Software: Which Is Better?

Working out the best choice between off-the-shelf and custom software can be a challenge and require deep research. We prepared the table below to show the main difference between these two solutions in a simple and easy to comprehend way.

While off-the-shelf options can seem cost-effective, they may not fit your long-term business plan if you have specific ideas in mind. Alternatively, investing in tailored solutions could give you more control over development but require extra effort to manage it moving forward. Ultimately, which solution will make your business efficient? Only the software that can appropriately support your unique situation will yield successful results.

See Also

• Tek Eye has other articles related to IT requirements
• For a full list of all the articles in Tek Eye see the full site Index.